The Bake Shop

Imperfect Perfection

Doughnuts

The Cider Mill’s old-fashioned, cake-batter doughnuts are delightfully irregular in shape—crisp on the outside, tender on the inside, and absolutely delicious. We like to call them “imperfect perfection.”

They pair perfectly with coffee, but they’re truly at their best alongside a glass of fresh cider.

Daily Flavors

Plain Cinnamon Powdered Sugar

Weekday-Only Flavors (Monday–Friday)

Chocolate Chocolate Peanut Maple Maple Walnut

Fact: Our doughnuts are made fresh throughout the day—never reheated or left over—so you always get them warm and at their best.

Baked Daily

Cookies

Our cookies are baked fresh daily and come in a variety of delicious flavors, ensuring there’s always something to satisfy your sweet tooth. From classic favorites to seasonal specialties, each batch is made with high-quality ingredients for a homemade taste you’ll love. Stop by The Cider Mill to see what’s available today and enjoy a warm, fresh-baked treat!

Flaky & Golden

Fresh Pies

Our pies are baked fresh every day in a variety of flavors, offering the perfect balance of flaky, golden crust and rich, flavorful fillings. Whether you’re craving a classic apple pie, a tart cherry delight, or a seasonal specialty, there’s always something delicious waiting for you. Stop by The Cider Mill to pick up a fresh-baked pie and enjoy a true taste of homemade goodness!

Warm & Homemade

Fresh Bread

Our bakery offers freshly baked breads every day in a variety of flavors, each made with high-quality ingredients for a warm, homemade taste. Visit The Cider Mill to explore our daily selection and take home a fresh, flavorful loaf!