While our fresh-pressed cider is the heartbeat of our operation, our shop is the soul. We’ve carefully curated a collection of goods that capture the spirit of an upstate New York autumn. From pantry essentials that elevate your kitchen to unique tokens that celebrate our history, our shelves are stocked with treasures waiting to be discovered.
A Taste of Tradition
We believe in the power of local flavors. Our retail area features a rotating selection of items that pair perfectly with our bakery goods and fresh apples:
Premium & Local New York State Cheeses
We’ve searched near and far to bring you an incredible selection of premium cheeses, proudly sourcing from local suppliers with the majority coming straight from Ovid, NY and around the beautiful Finger Lakes region. They make the perfect pairing for a crisp Cider Mill apple or a fresh slice of pie!
Stop in to explore our full selection, including:
- The Classics: Rich, smooth Cheddar and our signature, well-aged Sharp Cheddar crafted in the traditional style.
- Favorites: Savory Garlic & Herb, perfectly marbled Marble Jack, and a spicy kick of Pepper Jack.
- Selections: Distinctive, rich Smoked Gouda and an exceptional, traditional Raw Whole Milk Gouda.
- Flavored Cheese Curds: Fresh, snackable, and delightfully squeaky cheese curds available in a variety of fun, savory flavors.
Gourmet & Local Specialty Foods & Pantry Staples The perfect companion for our fresh-baked breads and a staple for any holiday table, our expanded specialty food aisles capture the very best flavors of the harvest and our region. From our own exclusive recipes to legendary local favorites and premium national brands, we’ve curated a massive selection you won't find anywhere else.
- Our Signature Cider Mill Brand: Stock your pantry with our private-label line of gourmet goods, including sweet jams, jellies, preserves, and rich apple butters. Looking for something savory or a little kick? We also carry our own specialty hot sauces, BBQ sauces, salad dressings, juices, cocktail mixes, fresh salsas, and crisp pickles—and that’s just the beginning!
- Proudly Supporting Local Favorites: We are passionate about keeping it local, bringing you the finest regional products from right here in our neighborhood and across Upstate New York. Stop in to grab trusted staples and treats from:
- Little Venice (Binghamton, NY) – Iconic pasta sauces
- Caccitore's (Johnson City, NY) – Celebrated local Italian specialties
- Lupo’s (Endicott, NY) – Home of the famous local spiedie marinades and sauces
- Aiello’s (Whitney Point, NY) – Beloved regional Italian favorites
- Kutil’s Honey (Oxford, NY) – Pure, golden local honey
- Split Maple Farms (Whitney Point, NY) – Authentic, rich NYS maple syrup
- New Hope Mills (Auburn, NY) – Traditional, classic pancake and baking mixes
- Chocolate Pizza Company (Marcellus, NY) – Unique, gourmet chocolate treats
- Nitro Brothers (Elmira, NY) – Bold, locally crafted cold brew coffees
An Unmatched Stonewall Kitchen Selection: While other local retailers might carry three or four Stonewall Kitchen items, we proudly showcase an extensive collection of over one hundred of their premium products! Explore a massive variety including rich alfredo and specialty sauces, savory pestos, cocktail mixes, gourmet mustards, marinades, jams, jellies, marmalades, barbecue sauces, salad dressings, and easy baking mixes, alongside specialized kitchen items.
Baking & Soup Mixes (Including Gluten-Free!): Baking delicious comfort food at home has never been easier. We proudly carry a wide selection of premium Mom's Place Gluten-Free baking mixes so everyone can enjoy fresh-baked treats. We also stock a huge lineup of Rabbit Creek baking mixes for warm scones, fruit fritters, and artisan breads, as well as their hearty, comforting gourmet soup mixes.
Unique Finds for the Kitchen & Home
Beyond the pantry, our gift shop is filled with a carefully curated collection of high-quality kitchenware, beautiful home accents, and unique gifts. It’s the perfect place to find a thoughtful housewarming present, a holiday surprise, or a beautiful new upgrade for your own home!
Stop in to browse our incredible selection, including:
- Entertaining & Display: Stunning charcuterie boards, premium cutting boards, elegant glassware, handcrafted pottery, and beautiful serving trays designed to elevate any gathering.
- Bakeware & Cookware: High-quality bakeware and a wide array of durable kitchen utensils and tools built for your favorite family recipes.
- Smart Kitchen Solutions: Clever, reliable food storage options and an ever-changing selection of handy kitchen gadgets that bring fun and efficiency to everyday cooking.
From timeless decor to the latest culinary tools, there is always something new and unexpected waiting to be discovered down our gift shop aisles!
A Destination for Everyone
The Cider Mill is more than a stop for snacks—it’s a destination. Whether you’re picking up a hostess gift, treating yourself to a local delicacy, or grabbing a souvenir to remember your trip, our shop is filled with the same care and quality you’ve come to expect from our kitchen.
Come browse the shelves
Our retail area is open daily alongside the farmstand and bakery.
