Our Goods

N.Y.S. Apples

With no orchards of our own, The Cider Mill has always been free to seek the best new apple varieties as they become available. We can also buy where the crop is best. As a result, our patrons know to expect consistently premium cider from The Cider Mill, as well as the largest and finest choice of fresh-picked apple varieties for eating, baking, or preserving from The Cider Mill Farmstand.

Apple Cider and Slushies

A naturally refreshing extraction of freshly squeezed apples that begins in August with the sweet, mellow taste of the early varieties. The flavor subtly changes throughout the season until the deep, full bodied tang of late ripening apples enriches each pressing.

Fact: Cider must be either pasteurized (brought to 160°F and immediately chilled) or passed through a UV Light Cider Processor. Cider Mill cider has been UV Light processed since 2016.

Candy Apples

Choice eating apples are punctured through the core with stout wooden handles and coated in sweet, premium syrups. At The Cider Mill, you must make a tough choice from a rainbow of flavors.

Available in seven traditional candy flavors:
Caramel, Cherry, Cinnamon, Grape, Lime, Strawberry, & Raspberry.

Fact: We never hide poor apples in a candy coating. You can be sure every Cider Mill Candy Apple began with a premium, unblemished apple grown for fresh eating enjoyment — a very healthy finish to a favorite treat.


The Cider Mill old-fashioned, cake-batter doughnuts tend to be irregularly round, slightly crisp on the outside, and wondrously scrumptious on the inside. We call it, “imperfect perfection”!

Great with coffee, but best with cider.

Available any day:
Plain, Cinnamon, & Powdered Sugar

Available Monday – Friday only:
Chocolate, Chocolate Peanut, Maple, Maple Walnut

Fact: The Cider Mill’s doughnuts are freshly made every day, and all day, as needed. They are never held over or reheated.


A variety of cookies.Our cookies are available daily in different varieties.

Fresh Pies

Fresh pie.

Our pies are available daily in different varieties.

Fresh Bread

Fresh warm bread.Fresh Breads are available in our bakery on a daily basis in different varieties.

Cheddar Cheese

Cheese!There are those of us who savor the cross-tastes: sweet & sour, tart & salt, sweet & dry, sweet & sharp. Every Fall of the year, it’s good to have a slice or two of cheese to counterpoint a tartly sweet apple, or a draught of The Cider Mill’s best.

Available by pound pricing:
Sharp Cheddar

Fact: It was many years before The Cider Mill found a source for the very high quality cheddars, aged to perfection in round wooden boxes, that seemed to have the subtleties of taste we held in memory. Please, sample for yourself.


Our pumpkin patch.There are plenty of fall sights outside in our farmstand each season. Our pumpkins come from Lancaster County, Pennsylvania.  We offer lots of harvest time decorations, gourds, fresh fall mums and Halloween pumpkins galore.